Device Redesign User Test​

Lead Designer
Native App
Proptech SaaS

Dashboard Redesign

In an effort to improve our smart home app, I designed and tested new device control ideas. Currently the device controls require two taps and a screen change. 

My hypothesis is that users would prefer a 1 tap experience and control all their devices from the dashboard screen.

Below are the test results:

Current Design

New Design #1

New Design #2

Dashboard Conclusion

As we see from the results above the single tap designs cut the users time in half and specially New Design #1 had the lowest mis-click rate and highest usability score. This verified the hypothesis I had that by simplifying the device design we could improve usability.

Thermostat Redesign

Another device redesign i was interested in testing was our thermostat design. I thought that the current design could confuse the user. My goal was to come up with a design that clearly showed the user the current temperature and what is was set to. I also wanted to show the user the other options their thermostat provided.

Current Design

New Design

What is the current temperature?

Current Design

Results

Current Temp 72: 74 responses

Current Temp 74: 24 responses

New Design

Results

Current Temp 72: 2 responses

Current Temp 75: 96 responses

As you can see there was clearly confusion on the current design regarding the current temperature. Clearly users thought that the largest number represented the temperature inside their home

What is the current fan mode?

Current Design

Results

On: 34 responses

Other: 64 responses

New Design

Results

On: 59 responses

Other: 39 responses

Which design do you prefer?

Current Design

Results

19%

New Design

Results

81%

Thermostat Conclusion

As we see from the results the new thermostat design conveys the information in a much more clear and concise way. It is not only an improvement on usability the users also preferred the design ascetically. I would say this is slam dunk change.